Shop for All Your Loved Ones With Drew and Jonathan’s 2026 Valentine’s Day Gift Guide

“Zooey and I love a good puzzle or mystery. One of our first dates was at an escape room! (Clearly, my Sherlock skills impressed her.) And if you’re anything like us, then you and your partner will have so much fun with this at-home murder mystery game you can play together. It’s to die for…” –Jonathan

“Sometimes, it doesn’t take something super over-the-top to feel sentimental. Do you have a favorite picture of you and your partner? What about that candid you snapped on family vacation? A framed photo really can be worth a thousand words.” –Drew

“If a home-cooked meal is their ultimate love language, you really can’t go wrong with a recipe book. They can write out all their best meals and family favorites, and you can even personalize the cover.” –Jonathan

“Personalized pieces are always going to make them feel special. And when it’s something they’ll use all the time, like a compact mirror? Even better. Every time they pull it out of their bag they’ll be reminded of you (and your great taste in gifting, of course).” –Drew

“It’s so easy for us to keep our favorite photos stuck on our phones, only to never see the light of day again. Surprise them by bringing your memories out of the digital album and into a customized photo book. You can include all your favorite pictures together from vacation or special moments you shared over the past year..” –Jonathan

“Linda and I love cuddling up with the kids for a good movie night. Make it extra-special this Valentine’s Day with a heart-shaped blanket! It even has a little pocket to keep your toes warm. It’d make the most adorable pillow fort top layer, too. –Drew

“Valentine’s Day candies are always a nice touch, but what do you do if the person you’re gifting likes the savory stuff? Charcuterie board lovers and sweet tooths alike are going to flip for this tinned fish set. It even comes with some recipes.” –Jonathan

“It’s the age-old problem that comes to every parent eventually: The kids want a pet that might not be very, let’s say, practical. (Sometimes a koala just isn’t in the cards…) But that doesn’t mean you can’t find them something that looks like the animals they’re begging you for, like these cute crochet jungle friends.” –Drew

“Valentine’s Day is pretty much your excuse for an all-day cookie-baking contest. This kit makes for a fun afternoon with the kids, friends, or a partner. After all, the couple that bakes together stays together—that’s what they say, right?” –Jonathan

“If your little ones are at that age where they want to listen to music or a fun story but you don’t want to hand them a screen just yet, a portable player like this will pretty much change your life. They can dive into anything from podcasts to learning lessons and books—all without a screen in sight.” –Drew

“Wedding memorabilia can be hit or miss sometimes, but this pick is pretty special. You can customize it with your wedding date and venue, and even personalize the dancers to look like you. Could be great for an anniversary gift, too.” –Drew